White Queerness, Black Alienation: Exploring the Link Between Racialized Transmisogyny and White Queer Racism

Laverne Cox’s Speech: http://everydayfeminism.com/2014/12/laverne-cox-intersection-what-to-do/

In a speech on the intersections of racism, transphobia, and misogyny, Lavern Cox, black transgender actress and activist, identifies ways that hate crimes against members of the LGBTQIAP+ community disproportionately target trans women of colour. She proposes that most violence aimed at queer people, regardless of whether they are cisgender or transgender, is derived from a desire in the mainstream to enforce binary models of gender performativity. As a black trans woman, Cox also discusses encountering transmisogyny at the hands of black cisgender men in a way that her white trans counterparts do not: she immediately counters the notion that black men are more transphobic, and instead identifies racial trauma as contributing to black male unease with black trans women. Cox attributes the trauma to slavery and Jim Crow era lynchings, during which “the men’s genitals were cut off [and kept by white lynchers, betraying a] historic fear and fascination with black sexuality” (Cox). According to her, some cisgender black people see her “trans woman’s body, and feel that [it is] the embodiment of this historical emasculation” (Cox). Quoting Cornell West’s statement that “justice is what love looks like in public,” Cox suggests that to counter transmisogynistic, racialized violence and bigotry, there needs to be honest, genuine communication stemming from a place of love. As long as white members of the LGBTQIAP+ community blame and alienate black people, and present whiteness as ubiquitous with queerness and transness, the world is made exponentially more dangerous for trans women of colour, and black trans women in particular.

Stereotyping black communities as being more transmisogynistic, transphobic, and homophobic than any other racial group fosters white supremacy: it functions to erase systemic oppression on multiple axes, putting the onus on black people for the perpetuation of violence and bigotry against the LGBTQIAP+ community. When whiteness is seen as synonymous with queerness, the priorities of white, economically advantaged, cisgender community members become the sole focus of LGBTQIAP+ activism and organizing, leaving trans women of colour vulnerable to systemic violence and exploitation. With the trans community already marginalized within mainstream LGBTQIAP+ organizing, the role of white supremacy serves to utterly devalue and alienate trans women of colour. In an article for Slate Magazine, journalist Parker Marie Molloy uses the suicide of Leelah Alcorn to critique the media’s pattern of ignoring racialized transmisogyny: when “trans women of colour [are] murdered at a rate of roughly one per week, [the media should] recognize this violence for what it is—an epidemic” (Molloy). While the reaction to Alcorn’s death is good, the contrasting lack of regard for the lives and deaths of trans women of colour highlights the degree to which only white lives are valued by the media and mainstream LGBTQIAP+ community.

A troubling historical precedent of ignoring trans women of colour exists within the LGBTQIAP+ community: journalist Eunbyul Lee points to the Stonewall Riots as “a classic example of the whitewashing of trans legacies. [While Stonewall is lauded] as a cornerstone of the white gay liberation movement…crucial TWOC leaders like Sylvia Rivera, Marsha P. Johnson, and Miss Major [are ignored and erased]” (Lee). The whitewashing of trans and queer history serves to reinforce that these marginalized sexual and gender identities are inherently white, and positions trans women of colour as aberrations. It is not difficult, then, to see why the street harassment Lavern Cox experiences from black men is derived from a sense that she is “a disgrace to the race because [she is] trans” (Cox). For decades, white gay and lesbian movements have actively set themselves in opposition to blackness as a means of gaining social status and security. Instead of recognizing the marginalization black trans women experience, they actively distance themselves, and present white gay and lesbian identity as confined to a gender binary and social normative. In order to achieve acceptance within a heteropatriarchal, white supremacist, imperialist society, “[white] gay and lesbian [activism lays] claims to imperilled domesticity, privacy, and kinship” (Bassichis, Spade 195). The emphasis on marriage equality—compared to the lack of focus or resources directed towards violence against trans women of colour—illustrates the desire among white, cis, middle-to-upper class queer people to integrate into an oppressive system. Other projects, like Dan Savage’s It Gets Better campaign, also illustrate “a form of gayness implicitly linked to whiteness and upward mobility” (196) and “generalize a particular narrative in which white queers can ‘escape’ homophobia…[unlike] queer and trans people who will remain targets of policing [and other state sanctioned violence]” (196). Trans and queer people of colour cannot attain the social status afforded white, cisgender gay people, or participate in respectability politics that treat cis, white bodies as normative, and trans, non-white bodies as Other. If LGBTQIAP+ politics make inclusion within the state a priority, they invariably participate in a system that devalues black life. From housing and employment discrimination to criminalization and mass incarceration, black people, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity, are harmed by the institutions to which white, cis gay and lesbian organizers look for validation and support (200).

White discourse within mainstream gay and lesbian politics frequently places the blame for homophobic legislation upon black voters, as with the passing of Proposition 8 in California, during which white, cis, gay organizers actively accused black people of being more homophobic than white people (197). When white, middle-to-upper class subsets of the community are actively dismissive of and hostile to the ongoing struggle for black humanity to be recognized and defended, cisgender, heterosexual people of colour are implicitly taught to connect LGBTQIAP+ organizing with their racial trauma. As Laverne Cox points out, the homicide rate for trans women of colour is the “highest in the LGBTQ community [comprising] 54% of all LGBTQ homicides” (Cox). This damaging and dishonest binary between white queerness and blackness ensures that trans women of colour, and black trans women especially, have no community to turn to for support and protection. To reduce violence against trans women of colour, it is vital that mainstream LGBTQIAP+ organizations actively address the racism they perpetuate, and work to provide support for trans and queer women of colour.

Until next time!

-Darkling

Works Cited

Bassichis, Morgan, and Dean Spade. “Queer Politics and Anti-Blackness.” Queer Necropolitics. Eds. Jin Haritaworn, Adi Kuntsman, Silvia Posocco. New York: Routledge, 2014. 191-203. Print.

Cox, Laverne. “Laverne Cox Explains the Intersection of Transphobia, Racism, and Misogyny (And What to Do About It).” Everyday Feminism. 7 Dec. 2014. Web. 6 Mar. 2015.     <http://everydayfeminism.com/2014/12/laverne-cox-intersection-what-to-do/&gt;

Molloy, Parker Marie. “Trans Women of Color Deserve to be Mourned as Much as Leelah Alcorn.” Slate. 13 Feb. 2015. Web. 7 Mar. 2015. <http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/ 2015/02/13while_the_media_focuses_on_leelah_alcorn_murders_of_trans_women_of _color.html>

Lee, Eunbyul. “Who Gets to be Human in Death?: Leela Alcorn and Trans Legacies.” Black Girl Dangerous. 6 Jan. 2015. Web. 9 Mar. 2015. <http://www.blackgirldangerous.org/ 2015/01/gets-human-death-leelah-alcorn-trans-legacies/>

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “White Queerness, Black Alienation: Exploring the Link Between Racialized Transmisogyny and White Queer Racism

  1. Moira

    Hi Darkling – thank you for your fantastic post! I really enjoyed reading your work. There were several ideas in here I found especially interesting; firstly, I was excited to see your engagement with the idea that black men are “more homophobic”, “more transphobic”, etc.. I think that these sort of observations are never as simple as they seem, and you are totally correct in associating them with legacies of trauma. I also really appreciated your reintroduction of the concept of black respectability politics – how IS a black, trans body supposed to negotiate this? White supremacist heteropatriarchal (ugh mouthful) Western society has really stuck black trans individuals with a heavy load to shoulder – they cannot “blend”, they face racism, sexism, trans-misogyny. Thank you for going beneath the surface and dredging up some really interesting, complex issues that relate to this video clip! I am looking forward to your next post!

    Like

    Reply
  2. Elin

    Hi Darkling,

    The articulation and eloquence in which this piece is written is outstanding! I thought that your commentary on Laverne Cox’s speech brought to light some important realities that take place currently in society which often are not given the attention that they deserve. In particular, your analysis of the adverse implications that the stereotype of “black communities as being more transmisogynistic, transphobic, and homophobic than any other racial group” and the resulting erasure of the role that other power structures subsequently play in these acts of violence and discrimination against LGBTQIAP+ individuals. Further, your inclusion of the construct of whitewashing in your analysis added to the depth of your discussion and greatly strengthened your argument. At the end of your piece you mention that in order to reduce established levels of violence harboured towards “trans women of colour” a shift in LGBTQIAP+ organizations ideology is necessary, how much of the onus do you believe follows on the heteropatriarchal and heteronormative power structures?

    ~Elin

    Like

    Reply
  3. Rosa Queen

    Hey Darkling!
    I would just like to start off by saying that you bring your points to life with such passion and eloquence that it is hard not to be completely moved by your argument! I love how you better illustrated the norms associated with the LGBTQ community, being white, and the further alienation due to colour even within this already discriminated group. You presented ideas that I would not have been able to identify without your well researched blog. I also found it intriguing that there is such a huge split between the struggles of LGBTQ white individuals and LGBTQ coloured individuals, such that the struggles of the first group go towards fitting into the already existing society through marriage equality, whilst the latter struggles to gain basic human rights. And what do we constantly hear about in the news regarding the LGBTQ community? The marriage equality issue. Even though the more pressing issue would be the violence perpetrated against coloured LGBTQ people, especially black MTF individuals. What this goes to show us is the precedence of the white dominated power structure over the basic needs of coloured individuals. I’m also glad you brought up the point of whitewashing of trans histories. What this does is further establish white normalcy in this population and further alienate those individuals that do not identify with this structure. Although I am not saying marriage equality isn’t also a problem that needs to be addressed, I personally believe that the rights to live of coloured trans and other LGBTQ individuals should be recieving more media attention. How can we actively change the conversation between marriage equality and basic human rights?
    Thanks again for a great post!

    -Rosa Queen

    Like

    Reply
  4. gndsgirl11

    Darkling,

    I first off all would like to start off by asking two things (due to my own ignorance and lack of education on this front), what exactly were the Stonewall
    Riots and Proposition 8?
    Moving forward, I found it very interesting how both of our blogs took such a different view on the Laverne Cox video, yours being more broad than mine. It was a very educational post and I really appreciated what you had to say about the topic. Due to the fact you know more about all of this than I do, it was a good read for me as I was able to learn and understand more about the history of this topic. I liked how you incorporated the diversity between whiteness and black trans aggression. You made many very interesting and good points about the issue, and I really enjoyed seeing your opinions on how you think that society could improve their ways of thinking in regards to the issue of lack of acceptance which is so prominent in today’s society.

    Thank you again for your views,
    gndsgirl11

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s